Many games do not let players plan their actions accurately beyond a certain point. This Limited Planning Ability can exist because players do not have all the information, because future actions and events are difficult to foresee, or because players simply do not have the time to do the planning. It may force players to take chances, quicken gameplay, and give players unexpected experiences.
Example: Deathmatches in multiplayer first-person shooters give players very little chance to plan while playing the game, since all other players are actively trying to eliminate them.
Example: The planning in most gambling games is very limited with the exception for long-term strategies regarding money.
Limited Planning Ability can be achieved through several different approaches: limiting the amount of things that can be planned, making events unpredictable, or limiting the time players have to plan. The first approach can easily be achieved by giving players a Limited Set of Actions but does not in itself give Limited Planning Ability if players have any Freedom of Choice.
The second approach, Limited Foresight, can either be achieved by making the effects of actions difficult to predict or by limiting the information available to judge the values of different actions and plans. The former relies on Imperfect Information, Uncertainty of Information, or actions that do not have Predictable Consequences, with Randomness and Multiplayer Games being the most common ways to achieve this. The latter does not automatically make consequences more difficult to predict, but the difficulty to do so can be increased by using Secret Resources, Preventing Goals, Player Decided Results, and Player-Defined Distribution of Rewards & Penalties.
The third approach is easily implemented through Time Limits. Real-Times Games can be used to create Limited Planning Ability, as they put a natural Time Limit on how much time players have until either they must reach to other players actions or before the game state has changed so much due to The Show Must Go On that the previous planning is outdated.
Limited Planning Ability makes gameplay mentally easier as focus is shifted from planning to doing, which limits the likelihood of Analysis Paralysis to occur. Limiting the planning can thereby make Cognitive Immersion less common but makes already existing possibilities for Spatial Immersion easier. Depending on the intended gameplay, this can be used to have the Right Level of Complexity by modulating how much players can plan. However, Limited Planning Ability gives players less Freedom of Choice and can thereby negatively affect any Illusion of Influence.
When players have Limited Planning Abilities in Multiplayer Games, this limits the likelihood that Downtime occurs for the other players. In Single-Player Games, the use of Limited Planning Abilities usually sets the Right Level of Difficulty or allows players to have Surprises due to Limited Foresight.
Instantiates: Spatial Immersion
Instantiated by: Limited Foresight, Time Limits, Player Decided Results, Preventing Goals, Secret Resources, Uncertainty of Information, Randomness, The Show Must Go On, Right Level of Difficulty, Right Level of Complexity
(C) Æliens 04/09/2009You may not copy or print any of this material without explicit permission of the author or the publisher. In case of other copyright issues, contact the author.